| 3,530 | 53 | 365 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
主体教育是现代教育的根本任务之一。教育学家格特·比斯塔揭示，受一系列当代教育趋势影响，主体教育正在淡出当代西方教育领域。“学习”和“发展”话语已主导教育领域的语言；对教育效能的过度关注正使教育顺应测量和循证文化；依此出台的各种标准使教育处于技术理性的控制下，教育者失去进行教育性判断的空间；教师和教学正被边缘化；日益工具化视角下的教育几乎遮蔽了教育的解放性。在对这些教育趋势进行批判反思的同时，他重申主体教育的重要性，构建出其主体化教育理论。文章在比斯塔著作语境和当代西方教育现实境脉下系统分析该教育理论出现、生成和发展的过程，以形成对该理论的整体理解并辨析其独特性，进而分析其对当下主体教育发展所具有的意义。
Abstract：Subject education is one of the fundamental tasks in modern education. Gert Biesta reveals that subject education almost disappears under several tendencies in our time. The language of learning and development has replaced the language of education. Too much focus on educational effectiveness has pushed education to follow the culture of measurement and evidence-based practice, resulting in standards that put education under the control of technological rationality, with little space for educators to exercise educational judgment. Teachers and teaching are thus marginalized. The increasing instrumentalization view of education has greatly obscured the emancipatory dimension of education. Alongside these analyses, Biesta reclaims the importance of subjectification and forms a theory. This article analyzes the emergence, formation, and development process of Biesta's theory of subjectification in the educational context of the Western world, identifying its specificity based on a holistic understanding of it. This article further analyzes the significance of this theory to the development of subject education.
[1] 岳伟，许元元.改革开放40年我国主体教育研究的回顾与展望[J].教育研究与实验，2019(1):38-45.
[2] 冯建军.主体教育研究40年：中国特色教育学建设的案例与经验[J].中国教育科学，2021(4):8-19.
[3] Biesta G.From Experimentalism to Existentialism:Writing in the Margins of Philosophy of Education[A].Waks,L.J.(Ed.).Leaders in Philosophy of Education.[C].Rotterdam:Sense Publishers,2014:13-30.
[4] Biesta,G.The Rediscovery of Teaching[M].London:Routledge,2017:1.
[5] Oral,S.Complicating Gert Biesta's Account of Subjectification:?I?ekian Negativity and Buddhist ■nyatā [J].Interchange:A Quarterly Review of Education,2016(2) :211-227.
[6] Portin,F.The Diplomatic Teacher:The Purpose of the Teacher in Gert Biesta's Philosophy of Education in Dialogue with the Political Philosophy of Bruno Latour[J].Studies in Philosophy and Education,2020(5):533-548.
[7] Brodie-McKenzie,A.Empowering Students as Citizens:Subjectification and Civic Knowledge in Civics and Citizenship Education[J].Journal of Applied Youth Studies,2020(3):209-222.
[8] Biesta,G.Education as Practical Intersubjectivity:Towards a Critical-Pragmatic Understanding of Education[J].Educational Theory,1994(3):299-317.
[9] Biesta,G.Pedagogy without Humanism:Foucault and the Subject of Education[J].Interchange:A Quarterly Review of Education,1998(1):1-16.
[10] [德]迪特里希·本纳，彭韬.教养—素养—能力——对学校教育目的和教育研究的反思[J].全球教育展望，2022(2):3-14.
[11] Biesta,G.Against Learning.Reclaiming a Language for Education in an Age of Learning[J].Nordisk Pedagogik,2005 (1):54-66.
[12][13][14][15][16][17][18] [荷]格特·比斯塔.超越人本主义教育：与他者共存[M].杨超，冯娜，译.北京：北京师范大学出版社，2020[2006]:13,27-32,94,104,135,54,144.
[19][22][23][24][25][26][54] [荷]格特·比斯塔.测量时代的好教育[M].张立平，韩亚菲，译.北京：北京师范大学出版社，2019[2010]:18,53,51,58,87,82,104.
[20] Biesta,G.Why “What Works” Won't Work:Evidence-based Practice and the Democratic Deficit of Educational Research[J].Educational Theory,2007(1):1-22.
[21] Biesta,G.Why “What Works” Still Won't Work:From Evidece-based Education to Value-based Education[J].Studies in Philosophy and Education,2010(5):491-503.
[27][29] [荷]格特·比斯塔.教育的美丽风险[M].赵康，译.北京：北京师范大学出版社，2018[2013]:40,196.
[28][39][40][41][42][43][44][45][46][47][48][49][50] Biesta,G.World-centred Education:A View for the Present[M].London:Routledge,2021:vii,35,38,19,20,46,91,49,48,68,69,87,91.
[30][31][32][33][34][35][36][37][38][52] [荷]格特·比斯塔.重新发现教学[M].赵康，译.北京：北京师范大学出版社，2021:1,17,33,9,89,4,167,153,167,95.
[51] 鲁洁.论教育之适应与超越[J].教育研究，1996(2):3-6.
[53] Biesta,G.Holding Oneself in the World[A].Saeverot,H.(Ed.).Meeting the Challenges of Existential Threats Through Educational Innovation:A Proposal for an Expanded Curriculum[C].London/New York:Routledge,2021.
[55] 冯建军.类主体：生态文明教育的人性假设[J].教育研究，2019(2):17-24.
[56] Egéa-Kuehne,D.“Subjectification”:Biesta' Strong Link to Education[A].Kerdeman,D.Philosophy of Education Archive[C].Champaign,IL:University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign,2009:363-366.
[57] Christodoulou,M.Emancipation as Subjectification.A Critical Realist Reading of Biesta's Educational Philosophy[J].Journal of Critical Realism,2020(1):1-15.
[58] R?mer,T.A.Gert Biesta—Education Between Bildung and Post-structualism[J].Educational Philosophy and Theory,2021(1):34-45.
基本信息:
中图分类号:G40
引用信息:
[1]赵康.为什么当下要重申主体教育?——格特·比斯塔“主体化”教育理论的境脉、生成与意义[J].全球教育展望,2023,52(07):3-15.
2023-07-10
2023-07-10