| 1,745 | 12 | 216 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
近年来，北美乃至整个西方司法界对于社会暴力的治理范式经历了从基于报应性正义的惩戒向基于修复性正义的关系修复的转变。这一转变同时也为西方治理校园暴力、解决学生冲突提供了新思路，促进了报复、惩罚的“零容忍”政策转向修复、治疗的修复性教育实践。修复性教育实践通过促进学生积极参与和对话，满足学生的需求，从而弥补伤害，修复关系，并提升学生的冲突解决能力，进而促进校园暴力问题的解决，营造更为健康的学校氛围。在实际操作方面，修复性教育实践是一个从非正式到正式的连续体，类型多样，主要模式有修复会议、缔造和平圈、家庭小组会议和同伴调解等。修复性正义理论及其在教育中应用的国际经验，有助于我们对教育部新出台的《中小学教育惩戒规则》形成新的理解和认识。对于青少年违法违纪违德行为，我们更需要从学生身心健康及社会长远和谐的角度，探寻更有效的富有长远育人价值的替代性治理方案。
Abstract：In recent years, a paradigm transformation from punishment-oriented retributive justice to restitution-oriented restorative justice is occurring in North America and even the whole Western world. At the same time, this transformation also provides a new idea of school violence governance and student conflicts resolution for the western world, that is, from the “zero tolerance” policy to the restorative justice practice in education. By promoting students' active participation and dialogue, the restorative justice practice in education helps to meet students' needs, make up for injuries, rebuild relationships, and improve their conflict resolution skills, thus promoting the resolution of school violence and creating a healthier school climate. In the actual operation, the restorative justice practice in education is a continuum ranging from informal to formal, with various types, including restorative/community conference, peacemaking circles, family group conference and peer mediation. International experience of restorative justice theory and its application in education provides a new perspective for understanding the newly issued “Guidelines and Rules of Discipline for Primary and Secondary Schools” by the Ministry of Education of China. For the illegal behaviors in teenagers, we need to explore more effective and valuable alternatives from the perspective of students' physical and mental health and sustainable peaceful society.
[1] Gilligan,J.Preventing Violence [M].New York,NY:Thames & Hudson,2001:56-58.
[2] Gregory,A.,Skiba,R.J.& Noguera,P.A.The Achievement Gap and the Discipline Gap:Two Sides of the Same Coin?[J].Educational Researcher,2010(1):59-68.
[3] Morrison,B.E.& Vaandering,D.Restorative Justice:Pedagogy,Praxis,and Discipline [J].Journal of school violence,2012(2):138-155.
[4] 中华人民共和国教育部.中华人民共和国教育部令第49号.中小学教育惩戒规则(试行)[EB/OL].http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2020-12/29/content_5574650.htm,2020-12-23/2021-09-11.
[5] 储朝晖.教育惩戒艺术仍值得继续探索[EB/OL].中华人民共和国教育部.http://www.moe.gov.cn/jyb_xwfb/s5148/202101/t20210104_508598.html?authkey=boxdr3.,2021-01-04/2021-09-11.
[6] Noguera,P.Preventing and Producing Violence:A Critical Analysis of Responses to School Violence [J].Harvard Educational Review,1995(2):189-213.
[7] Adams,A.T.The Status of School Discipline and Violence [J].The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science,2000(1):140-156.
[8] Barnes,D.Restorative Peacemaking Circles and Other Conflict Management Efforts in Three Ontario High Schools [D].Toronto:University of Toronto,2015.
[9] Brock,M.,Kriger,N.& Miró,R.School Safety Policies and Programs Administered by the US Federal Government:1990-2016 [R].Washington,DC:Library of Congress,2017.
[10] Klehr,D.G.Addressing the Unintended Consequences of No Child Left Behind and Zero Tolerance:Better Strategies for Safe Schools and Successful Students [J].Geo.J.on Poverty L.& Pol'y,2009,16:585-610.
[11] Legislative Assembly of Ontario.Bill 81:An Act to Increase Respect and Responsibility,to Set Standards for Safe Learning and Safe Teaching in Schools and to Amend the Teaching Profession Act [EB/OL].https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/s00012,2000-06-23/2021-09-11.
[12] Monahan,K.C.,VanDerhei,S.,Bechtold,J.,et al.From the School Yard to the Squad Car:School Discipline,Truancy,and Arrest [J].Journal of youth and adolescence,2014(7):1110-1122.
[13] Gladden,R.M.Chapter 6:Reducing School Violence:Strengthening Student Programs and Addressing the Role of School Organizations [J].Review of research in education,2002(1):263-299.
[14] Teasley,M.L.Shifting from Zero Tolerance to Restorative Justice in Schools [J].Children & Schools,2014(3):131-133.
[15] Christle,C.A.,Jolivette,K.& Nelson,C.M.Breaking the School to Prison Pipeline:Identifying School Risk and Protective Factors for Youth Delinquency [J].Exceptionality,2005(2):69-88.
[16][18] Adams,A.T.The Status of School Discipline and Violence [J].The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science,2000(1):140-156.
[17] Children's Defense Fund.State of America's Children ? 2012 Handbook [EB/OL].https://www.alternet.org/2012/08/state-americas-children-2012/,2012-08-07/2021-09-11.
[19] Stinchcomb,J.B.,Bazemore,G.& Riestenberg,N.Beyond Zero Tolerance:Restoring Justice in Secondary Schools [J].Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice,2006(2):123-147.
[20] [41] González,T.Keeping Kids in Schools:Restorative Justice,Punitive Discipline,and the School to Prison Pipeline [J].Journal of Law and Education,2012(2):281-336.
[21] 陆诗忠.西方恢复性司法理论渊源之考究[J].北方法学，2012(5):116-125.
[22] 陈兴良.走向哲学的刑法学[M].北京：法律出版社，1999:285-286.
[23] 李建华，张善燚.修复性正义：基于刑事司法展开的伦理[J].道德与文明，2006(6):54-57.
[24] Schwartz,G.T.Mixed Theories of Tort Law:Affirming Both Deterrence and Corrective Justice [J].Texas Law Review,1996,75:1801-1834.
[25] Weiler,J.M.P.Why Do We Punish — The Case for Retributive Justice [J].University of British Columbia Law Review,1978(2):295-319.
[26] Potter,Jr.N.T.The Principle of Punishment Is a Categorical Imperative [A].Kneller,J.& Sidney Axinn,S.(Eds.).Autonomy and Community:Readings in Contemporary Kantian Social Philosophy [C].Albany,NY:State University of New York Press,1998:169-190.
[27][40] 陈晓明.论修复性司法[M].北京：法律出版社，2006:52-57.
[28] Quinn,T.J.Beyond Community Policing:Community Justice [J].Police Chief,1997,64:107-109.
[29] Blondel,E.C.Victims' Rights in an Adversary System [J].Duke Law Journal,2008,58:237-274.
[30] Barnett,R.E.Restitution:A New Paradigm of Criminal Justice [J].Ethics,1977(4):279-301.
[31] Marshall,T.F.The Evolution of Restorative Justice in Britain [J].European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research,1996(4):21-43.
[32] Braithwaite,J.Restorative Justice:Assessing Optimistic and Pessimistic Accounts [J].Crime and Justice,1999(1):1-127.
[33] Howard,Z.Changing Lenses:A New Focus for Crime and Justice [M].Waterloo:Herald Press,2005:211-212.
[34] Relief Web.Glossary of Humanitarian Terms [R].New York,NY:Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs Policy Development Studies Branch,2008:43.
[35] Johnstone,G.& Van Ness,D.W.The Meaning of Restorative Justice [A].Johnstone,G.& Van Ness,D.W.Handbook of Restorative Justice [C].Cullompton:Willan Publishing,2007:5-23.
[36] Schweigert,F.J.Moral and Philosophical Foundations of Restorative Justice [A].Perry,J.(Ed.).Restorative Justice:Repairing Communities through Restorative Justice [C].[S.l.]:American Correctional Association,2002:19-37.
[37] Zehr,H.The Little Book of Restorative Justice:Revised and Updated [M].New York,NY:Simon and Schuster,2015:17-20.
[38] Hopkins,B.Just Schools:A Whole School Approach to Restorative Justice [M].London:Jessica Kingsley Publishers,2003:20.
[39] Johnstone,G.& Van Ness,D.Handbook of Restorative Justice [M].New York,NY:Routledge,2013:589-591.
[42] Toews,B.The Little Book of Restorative Justice for People in Prison:Rebuilding the Web of Relationships [M].New York,NY:Simon and Schuster,2006:24.
[43] U.S.Department of Education.Joint “Dear Colleague” Letter.[EB/OL] https://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ocr/letters/colleague-201401-title-vi.html,2014-01-08/2021-09-11.
[44] Skiba,R.J.& Losen,D.J.From Reaction to Prevention:Turning the Page on School Discipline [J].American Educator,2016(4):4-11.
[45] Hopkins,B.Restorative Justice in Schools [J].Support for Learning,2002(3):144-149.
[46] Anfara,Jr.,V.A.,Evans,K.R.& Lester,J.N.Restorative Justice in Education:What We Know So Far [J].Middle School Journal,2013(5):57-63.
[47] Smith,L.C.,Garnett,B.R.,Herbert,A.,et al.The Hand of Professional School Counseling Meets the Glove of Restorative Practices:A Call to the Profession [J].Professional School Counseling,2017(1):1-10.
[48] Wachtel,T.Restorative Justice in Everyday Life:Beyond the Formal Ritual [J].Reclaiming Children and Youth,2003(2):83-87.
[49] 程力，沈晓敏.预防校园暴力：美国冲突解决教育的理论基础与实施路径[J].外国教育研究，2020(8):115-128.
[50] 彭斌.社会和解何以可能?——以恢复性正义为视角的分析[J].学术交流，2012(9):5-9.
[51] 何群.从惩罚正义到恢复性正义——读《犯罪、羞耻与重整》有感[J].人民检察，2015(9):69-70.
[52] 袁汝婷，等.教育惩戒权教师不敢接、不愿接举戒尺还须迈过几道坎?[EB/OL].半月谈，http://news.cctv.com/2019/12/02/ARTIcV7pZLs1xZJ0owJMKo3c191202.shtml,2019-12-02/2021-09-11.
[53] Varnham,S.Seeing Things Differently:Restorative Justice and School Discipline [J].Education and the Law,2005(3):87-104.
[54] 刘次林.教育惩戒亟须理性治理[J].上海师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2021(5):100-106.
基本信息:
中图分类号:G511
引用信息:
[1]程力,沈晓敏.从惩戒到关系修复：北美校园暴力治理范式的转变[J].全球教育展望,2022,51(04):112-128.
基金信息:
国家社会科学基金“十三五”规划2019年度教育学一般课题“中学生冲突解决能力培养研究”(项目编号：BEA190109); 2020年安徽省人文社会科学重点项目“基于能力培养的西方冲突解决教育研究”(项目编号：SK2020A0343)的研究成果之一
2021-09-11
2021
2021-12-03
2021
1
2022-04-10
2022-04-10