| 2,754 | 27 | 417 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
学习毅力一直以来被认为是影响学业表现提升和学习能力发展的重要非认知因素。学习者如何能克服困难和挫折，并长期坚持完成学习任务，这其中学习者的性格特征和行为又发挥了何种作用?如何能在技术媒体日益丰富的学习环境中不被外界打扰、保持专注力，专心完成学习任务?问题背后的发生机理也正受到研究者的重视，即如何真正了解什么是学习毅力。因此，本研究力图以现有学习毅力的相关理论、发生机制和已有模型为基础展开探索。首先，梳理不同学习场景及相关实证研究，进而选择依托交互决定论和中介变量理论，来比较现有学习毅力模型和非认知能力模型；其次，采用扎根理论对来自不同专业领域的23位一线教师的访谈文本内容进行质性分析，访谈主要是对学习毅力的理解、内涵和影响因素等问题的深度探讨；最后，结合理论基础和访谈分析结果，刻画学习毅力的可塑模型。研究发现，对学习毅力及其影响因素的理解和测量方法的归纳，可以从四个方面来综合分析，即学习者个体特征、语境特征、关系特征和学习环境特征。从“四特征”内涵入手刻画的模型相对全面地构建了学习者画像，为解决学习动力不足、培养和发展学习毅力提供了理论指导和实践借鉴。
Abstract：Learning perseverance has always been regarded as an important non-cognitive factor that affects the improvement of academic performance and the development of learning ability. However, how can learners overcome difficulties and frustrations and persist in completing learning tasks for a long time? What role do learners' character traits and behaviors play? How can learners stay focused and complete learning tasks without being disturbed by the outside world in the increasingly technology-rich learning environment? The mechanism behind the problem is also being valued by researchers, that is, how to truly understand what learning perseverance is. Therefore, this research attempts to explore the mechanism based on the existing relevant theories, and existing models of learning perseverance. Firstly, we sorted out different learning scenarios and related empirical research, and then chose to rely on the interaction determinism and the mediating variable theory to compare the existing learning perseverance model and the non-cognitive ability model. Secondly, we used the grounded theory to compare 23 first-line teachers from different disciplines. The teacher's interviews were qualitatively analyzed. The interview was mainly an in-depth discussion of the understanding, connotation and influencing factors of learning perseverance. Finally, combining theoretical foundation and interview analysis results, we portrayed a plastic model of learning perseverance. The study found that the understanding of learning perseverance and its influencing factors and the induction of measurement methods can be comprehensively analyzed from four aspects, namely, learner's individual characteristics, context characteristics, relationship characteristics, and learning environment characteristics. The model described from the connotation of the “four characteristics” constructs a relatively comprehensive portrait of learners, and provides theoretical guidance and practical reference for solving the lack of learning motivation and cultivating learning perseverance.
[1] Mutlu,G.& Y?ld?r?m,A.Learning Environment Perceptions and Student Background Variables as Determinants of Persistence in EFL Learning[J].SAGE Open,2019(4):1-17.
[2][33] DiCerbo,K.E.Game-based Assessment of Persistence[J].Journal of Educational Technology & Society,2014(1):17-28.
[3] Tran,Y.Computational Thinking Equity in Elementary Classrooms:What Third-grade Students Know and Can Do[J].Journal of Educational Computing Research,2019(1):3-31.
[4] Israel-Fishelson,R.& Hershkovitz,A.Persistence in a Game-based Learning Environment:The Case of Elementary School Students Learning Computational Thinking[J].Journal of Educational Computing Research,2020(5):891-918.
[5] Long,P.& Siemens,G.Penetrating the Fog:Analytics in Learning and Education[J].Educause Review,2011(5):31-40.
[6] 顾小清，胡艺龄.理解、设计和服务学习：学习分析技术的回顾与前瞻[J].开放教育研究，2020(2):40-42.
[7] Killingsworth,M.A.& Gilbert D.T.A Wandering Mind is an Unhappy Mind[J].Science,2010(6006):932-932.
[8] Liu,Y.& Gu,X.Media Multitasking,Attention,and Comprehension:A Deep Investigation into Fragmented Reading[J].Educational Technology Research and Development,2020(1):67-87.
[9] Schmidt,F.T.C.,Fleckenstein,J.,Retelsdorf,J.,Eskreis-Winkler,L.& M?ller,J.Measuring Grit[J].European Journal of Psychological Assessment,2019 (3):436-447.
[10] Farrington,C.A.,Roderick,M.,Allensworth,E.,et al.Teaching Adolescents to Become Learners:The Role of Noncognitive Factors in Shaping School Performance — A Critical Literature Review[M].Chicago,IL:Consortium on Chicago School Research,2012.
[11] National Research Council.Improving Adult Literacy Instruction:Options for Practice and Research[M].Washington,D.C.:National Academies Press,2012.
[12] Tough,P.How Children Succeed:Grit,Curiosity,and the Hidden Power of Character[M].Boston,MA:Houghton Mifflin Harcourt,2012.
[13] Woods-Groves,S.,Eaves,R.C.& Williams,J.T.O.Internal Consistency of the Human Behavior Rating Scale[J].Psychological Reports,2009(3):835-848.
[14] Cohen,R.M.Will Students Soon be Tested for “Grit”?The American Prospect[EB/OL].http://prospect.org/blog/tapped/will-students-soon-be-tested-grit.,2015-07-07/2021-05-16.
[15] OECD.Ready to Learn:Students' Engagement,Drive and Self-beliefs (Vol.III)[S].Paris:OECD,2013.
[16] Duckworth,A.L.,Peterson,C.,Matthews,M.D.& Kelly,D.R.Grit:Perseverance and Passion for Long-term Goals[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,2007(6):1087-1101.
[17] Credé,M.,Tynan,M.& Harms,P.D.Much Ado about Grit:A Meta-analytic Synthesis of the Grit Literature[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,2017(3):492-511.
[18] Loes,C.N.,An,B.P.,Saichaie,K.,et al.Does Collaborative Learning Influence Persistence to the Second Year of College?[J].The Journal of Higher Education,2017(1):62-84.
[19] Berhenke,A.,Miller,A.L.,Brown,E.,et al.Observed Emotional and Behavioral Indicators of Motivation Predict School Readiness in Head Start Graduates[J].Early Childhood Research Quarterly,2011(4):430-441.
[20] Murangi,K.,Perkins,R.C.& Tang,J.H.Findings and Recommendations from the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) 2017 Pilot Study of the Middle School Transcript Study (MSTS).Methodological Report[R].National Center for Education Statistics,2019.
[21] Flanagan,K.M.& Einarson,J.Gender,math Confidence,and Grit:Relationships with Quantitative Skills and Performance in an Undergraduate Biology Course[J].CBE — Life Sciences Education,2017(3):1-11.
[22] 杜宵丰，刘坚.八年级学生“数学兴趣”“数学自我效能感”“学习坚持性”与“数学成就”的关系研究[J].数学教育学报，2017(2):29-34.
[23] Duckworth,A.L.& Eskreis-Winkler,L.True Grit[J].Aps Observer,2013(4):1-3.
[24] Von Culin,K.R.,Tsukayama,E.& Duckworth,A.L.Unpacking Grit:Motivational Correlates of Perseverance and Passion for Long-term Goals[J].The Journal of Positive Psychology,2014(4):306-312.
[25] Disabato,D.J.,Goodman,F.R.& Kashdan,T.B.Is Grit Relevant to Well-being and Strengths?Evidence across the Globe for Separating Perseverance of Effort and Consistency of Interests[J].Journal of Personality,2019(2):194-211.
[26] 唐铭，刘儒德，高钦，庄鸿娟，魏军，邸妙词.调节聚焦对高中生毅力水平的影响：学业情绪的中介作用[J].心理与行为研究，2016(4):479-485.
[27] DiMenichi,B.C.& Richmond,L.L.Reflecting on Past failures Leads to Increased Perseverance and Sustained Attention[J].Journal of Cognitive Psychology,2015(2):180-193.
[28] Mrazek,A.J.,Ihm,E.D.,Molden,D.C.,Mrazek,M.D.,Zedelius,C.M.& Schooler,J.W.Expanding Minds:Growth Mindsets of Self-regulation and the Influences on Effort and Perseverance[J].Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,2018(6):164-180.
[29][42] Datu,J.A.D.,Yuen,M.& Chen,G.Development and Validation of the Triarchic Model of Grit Scale (TMGS):Evidence from Filipino Undergraduate Students[J].Personality and Individual Differences,2017(11):198-205.
[30] 雷万鹏，向蓉.学生科学素养提升之家庭归因——基于中国PISA2015数据的分析[J].全球教育展望，2020(9):66-78.
[31] 孙小坚，宋乃庆，梁学友.感知的父母及教师支持与学生STEAM学习的持续性动机：学习兴趣和自我效能感的多重中介作用[J].心理与行为研究，2021(1):37-44.
[32] Schunk,D.H.& Pajares,F.Self-efficacy Theory[A].K.R.Wentzel,K.R.& Wigfield,A.(Eds.),Handbook of Motivation at School [C].New York,NY:Routledge,2009:35-54.
[34] Farrington,C.A.,Roderick,M.,Allensworth,E.,Jenny,N.,Seneca,K.T.,David,W.J.& Nicole,O.B.Teaching Adolescents to Become Learners:The Role of Noncognitive Factors in Shaping School Performance — A Critical Literature Review[M].Chicago,IL:Consortium on Chicago School Research,2012.
[35][43] Bandura,A.Social Foundations of Thought and Action[M].Englewood Cliffs,NJ:Prentice-Hall,1986.
[36] Bandura,A.Social Cognitive Theory:An Agentic Perspective[J].Annual Review of Psychology,2001(1):1-26.
[37] Baron,R.M.& Kenny,D.A.The Moderator-mediator Variable Distinction in Social Psychological Research:Conceptual,Strategic,and Statistical Considerations[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1986(6):1173-1182.
[38] Glaser,B.G.,Strauss,A.L.& Strutzel,E.The Discovery of Grounded Theory;Strategies for Qualitative Research[J].Nursing Research,1968(4):364-364.
[39] Strauss,A.& Corbin,J.Grounded Theory Methodology:An Overview[A].Denzin,N.K.& Lincoln,Y.S.(Eds.),Handbook of Qualitative Research[C].London:Sage Publications,1994:1-18.
[40] Auerbach,C.& Silverstein,L.B.Qualitative Data:An Introduction to Coding and Analysis[M].New York,NY:New York Univetsity Press,2003:29-87.
[41] Dweck,C.S.Self-theories:Their Role in Motivation,Personality,and Development[M].New York,NY:Psychology Press,2013:1-43.
[44] Schunk,D.H.Modeling and Attributional Effects on Children's Achievement:A Self-efficacy Analysis[J].Journal of Educational Psychology,1981(1):93-105.
[45] Zimmerman,B.J.A Social Cognitive View of Self-regulated Academic Learning[J].Journal of Educational Psychology,1989(3):329-339.
[46] 石雪.混合式学习中大学生在线学习力的评价与提升研究[D].济南：山东师范大学，2020.
[47] Ventura,M.,Shute,V.& Zhao,W.The Relationship between Video Game Use and a Performance-based Measure of Persistence[J].Computers & Education,2013(1):52-58.
[48] Bunce,D.M.,Flens,E.A.& Neiles,K.Y.How Long Can Students Pay Attention in Class?A Study of Student Attention Decline Using Clickers[J].Journal of Chemical Education,2010(12):1438-1443.
[49] Rizzolatti,G.,Riggio,L.& Sheliga,B.M.Space and Selective Attention[A].Umiltà,C.& Moscovitch,M.(Eds.),Attention and Performance 15:Conscious and Nonconscious Information Processing [C].Cambridge,MA:The MIT Press,1994:231-265.
[50] Halverson,C.F.,Havill,V.L.,Deal,J.,et al.Personality Structure as Derived from Parental Ratings of Free Descriptions of Children:The Inventory of Child Individual Differences[J].Journal of Personality,2003(6):995-1026.
基本信息:
中图分类号:G442
引用信息:
[1]刘妍,管秀,顾小清.我们真的了解学习毅力吗?:基于扎根理论刻画教师视角的可塑模型研究[J].全球教育展望,2022,51(02):39-58.
基金信息:
国家社会科学基金“十三五”规划2020年度教育学青年课题“指向非认知能力的学习困难诊断及其多模态数据反馈研究”(项目编号：CCA200254)