学习机会视角下的单元教学设计——以GTI项目上海课件为分析对象的考察Unit Teaching Design from the Perspective of Opportunity to Learn——Investigation on Shanghai Artifact Component in GTI Project
安桂清,陈艳茹
摘要(Abstract)：
单元教学设计是撬动课堂转型的支点，也是落实学科核心素养的基本单位。本研究以OECD开展的全球教学洞察(GTI)项目中的上海课件为分析对象，在建构学习机会分析框架的基础上，从基于教学内容的学习机会设计和基于教学实践的学习机会设计两个方面考察上海课堂单元教学设计的基本情况。结果发现：当前单元教学设计重视技能训练、关注思维发展，但对关键能力培养的学习机会设计有待加强；单元教学设计虽然有明确的目标指向，但对学生差异化、自主性学习的引导有待深化；单元教学设计中技术的应用程度与作用方式有待进一步强化与完善。同时，该项研究对扩展和深化课堂研究提供了重要启示：关注课堂中的人工制品，扩展课堂研究的对象；重构学习机会的概念框架与测评方式，丰富课堂研究的视角；融入课堂多模态分析的发展趋势，展现课堂研究方法的创新。
关键词(KeyWords)： 单元教学设计;全球教学洞察(GTI)项目;课件;学习机会
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): 安桂清,陈艳茹
参考文献(References)：
- [1][14] 钟启泉.基于核心素养的课程与发展：挑战与课题[J].全球教育展望，2016(1):3-25.
- [2] 李磊.基于学科核心素养的学习单元设计研究[D] .上海：华东师范大学，2020.
- [3] 任明满.大单元教学：历史脉络、研究现状及路径选择[J].课程·教材·教法，2022(4):97-105.
- [4][11] [美]格兰特·威金斯，杰伊·麦克泰.理解为先的模式单元教学设计指南(一)[M].福州：福建教育出版社，2018:7,28-36.
- [5] OECD.Global Teaching InSights Technical Report and Instruments [R].Paris:OECD Publishing,2020.
- [6] 刘徽.“大概念”视角下的单元整体教学构型——兼论素养导向的课堂变革[J].教育研究，2020(6):64-77.
- [7] 雷浩，李雪.素养本位的大单元教学设计与实施[J].全球教育展望，2022(5):49-59.
- [8][31] OECD.When Practice Meets Policy in Mathematics Education:A 19 Country/Jurisdiction Case Study [EB/OL].https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/education/when-practice-meets-policy-in-mathematics-education_07d0eb7d-en,20202-08-20/2022-03-04.
- [9] 中华人民共和国教育部.义务教育数学课程标准(2022年版)[S].北京：北京师范大学出版社，2022.
- [10] 崔允漷.学科核心素养呼唤大单元教学设计[J].上海教育科研，2019(4):1.
- [12] [美]特蕾西·K.希尔.设计与运用表现性任务——促进学生学习与评估[M].杜丹丹，杭秀，译.福州：福建教育出版社，2019:5.
- [13] 邵朝友，陈体杰，杨宇凡.论单元核心学习任务的设计——基于目标—教学—评价一致性的视角[J].当代教育科学，2021(3):73-78.
- [15] 张良，罗生全.论“用以致学”:指向素养发展的教学认识论[J].华东师范大学学报(教育科学版),2021(2):40-49.
- [16] 熊梅，李洪修.发展学科核心素养：单元学习的价值、特征和策略[J].课程·教材·教法，2018(12):88-94.
- [17] 郭炯，潘霞.面向学科能力培养的单元教学设计模型研究[J].电化教育研究，2022(7):81-88.
- [18] 钟启泉.教学心理十讲[M].上海：华东师范大学出版社，2020:120-122.
- [19] 任明满.大单元教学：历史脉络、研究现状及路径选择[J].课程·教材·教法，2022(4):97-105.
- [20][37] Carroll,J.B.A Model for School Learning[J].Teachers College Record,1963(8):1-9.
- [21] Wiley,D.E.& Harnischfeger,A.Explosion of a Myth:Quantity of Schooling and Exposure to Instruction,Major Educational Vehicles [J].Educational Researcher,1974(4):7-12.
- [22] Stevens,F.I.Applying an Opportunity-to-learn Conceptual Framework to the Investigation of the Effects of Teaching Practices via Secondary Analyses of Multiple-case-study Summary Data [J].Journal of Negro Education,1993(3):232-248.
- [23] Kurz,A.,et al.Assessing Opportunity-to-learn for Students with Disabilities in General and Special Education Classes [J].Assessment for Effective Intervention,2014(1):24-39.
- [24] OECD.PISA 2012 Technical Report [EB/OL].http://www.oecd.org/pisa/pisaproducts/PISA-2012-technical-report-final.pdf,2016-11-24/2022-08-14.
- [25] Piasta,S.B.,et al.Mathematics and Science Learning Opportunities in Preschool Classrooms[J].Early Education and Development,2014(4):445-468.
- [26] Kurz,A.,Elliott,S.N.,Lemons,C.J.,et al.Assessing Opportunity-to-learn for Students with Disabilities in General and Special Education Classes [J].Assessment for Effective Intervention,2014(1):24-39.
- [27] Reeves,C.& Major,T.Using Student Notebooks to Measure Opportunity to Learn in Botswana and South African Classrooms [J].Prospects,2012(4):403-413.
- [28] Stols,G.An Investigation into the Opportunity to Learn that Is Available to Grade 12 Mathematics Learners [J].South African Journal of Education,2013(1):1-18.
- [29] T?rnroos,J.Mathematics Textbooks,Opportunity to Learn and Student Achievement [J].Studies in Educational Evaluation,2005(4):315-327.
- [30] OECD.Global Teaching InSights Technical Report (Section IV :Analysis) [EB/OL].https://www.oecd.org/education/school/GTI-TechReport-Chapter21.pdf,2022-05-02/2022-08-20.
- [32] McAdamis,S.Teachers Tailor Their Instruction to Meet a Variety of Student Needs [J].Journal of Staff Development,2001(2):1-5.
- [33] McQuarrie,L.M.& McRae,P.A Provincial Perspective on Differentiated Instruction:The Alberta Initiative for School Improvement (AISI) [J].Journal of Applied Research on Learning,2010(4):1-18.
- [34] Ramdass,D.& Zimmerman,B.J.Effects of Self-correction Strategy Training on Middle School Students' Self-efficacy,Self-evaluation,and Mathematics Division Learning [J].Journal of Advanced Academics,2008(1):18-41.
- [35] Kanuka,H.,Rourke,L.,& Laflamme,E.The Influence of Instructional Methods on the Quality of Online Discussion [J].British Journal of Educational Technology,2007(2):260-271.
- [36] 吴刚，赵军，苏静逸，谢鑫.“工作—学习”理论的创新与发展——第四代“文化—历史”活动理论及应用价值[J].远程教育杂志，2022(2):86-95.
- [38] 杨晓哲.基于人工智能的课堂分析架构：一种智能的课堂教学研究[J].全球教育展望，2021(12):55-65.