国外“教学学术”概念发展脉络演进Development of the Concept of “Scholarship of Teaching” Abroad
王宝玺,朱超颖
摘要(Abstract):
自博耶提出教学学术以来,国外对教学学术概念的研究大致可分为两个阶段。1990年至2000年是第一阶段,在这一阶段,博耶从教师作为一名"教育者"的角度提出教学学术这一概念,但并未对这一概念进行阐释,赖斯、斯科、克莱博和马丁等分别对博耶的概念进行完善。他们初步意识到教师也是一名"学习者",但并没有突破性概念的提出,只是对"教学学术"概念的外延进行了拓展。2001年至今是第二阶段,舒尔曼从教师作为"学习者"的视角对博耶提出的教学学术概念进行重新界定,把教学学术界定为"教与学的学术",提出"学习者共同体"概念,将教学学术从宏观引向微观。此后学者在实践、评估和反思等活动中对"教学学术"概念不断完善。
关键词(KeyWords): 博耶;教学学术;舒尔曼;教与学的学术
基金项目(Foundation): 2016教育部人文社科基金(项目编号:16YJA880041);; 江苏省高校哲学社会科学研究一般项目(项目编号:2016SJB880082)的阶段性成果
作者(Author): 王宝玺,朱超颖
参考文献(References):
- [1]Bender,E.T.Castls in the Air:The Sotl“Movement”in Mid-Flight[J].Change,2005(5):40-49.
- [2]Boyer,E.L.Scholarship Reconsidered:Priorities of the Professoriate[J].Academe,1990(1):151.
- [3]Boyer,E.L.Selected Speeches 1978-1995[M].San Francisco:Jossey-Bass Inc.,1997:9-109.
- [4]Boyer,E.L.Education Goals——An Action Plan[C].Washington,D.C.:The Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching Delivered at the National Governors'Association Winter Meeting,1990(25):495-497.
- [5]Rice,R.E.Towards a Broader Conception of Scholarship:The American context[C].Whiston,T.&Geiger(Eds.).Research and Higher Education:The United Kingdom and the United States[M].Buckingham:SRHE and Open University Press,1992:117-129.
- [6]Schon,D.A.The New Scholarship Requires a New Epistemology[J].Change,1995(6):27-34.
- [7]Martin,E.,Benjamin,J.,Prosser,M.&Trigwell,K.Scholarship of Teaching:A Study of the Approaches of Academic Staff[M].Oxford:Oxford Brookes University Press,1999:326-331.
- [8]Kreber,C.&Cranton,P.A.Exploring the Scholarship of Teaching[J].Journal of Higher Education,2000(4):476-495.
- [9]Atkinson,M.P.The Scholarship of Teaching and Learning:Reconceptualizing Scholarship and Transforming the Academy[J].Social Forces,2001(4):1217-1230.
- [10]朱雪文.彻底变革大学本科教育:美国研究型大学的蓝图[J].全球教育展望,2001(3):67.
- [11]《专访》记者.宗旨:促进人类的教学进步——美国卡内基教学促进基金会主席舒尔曼访谈录[J].教育发展研究,1998(8):66.
- [12]Kathleen Mc Kinney.Definitions of Scholarship of Teaching and Learning[EB/OL].http://www.stol.ilstu.edu/downloads/pdf/definesotl.pdf.2003-10-5/2016-9-19.
- [13]Shulman,L.S.Teaching as Community Property:Putting an End to Pedagogical Solitude[J].Change,1993(6):6-7.;
- [14]Shulman,L.S.Teaching as Community Property[M].San Francisco:Jossey-Bass,2004:163-172.
- [15]Shulman,L.S.From Minsk to Pinsk:Why a Scholarship of Teaching and Learning?[J].Journal of Scholarship in Teaching and Learning,2000(1):87-94.
- [16]Shulman,L.S.Teaching as Community Property:Essays on Higher Education[M].San Francisco:JosseyBase,2004:89-218.
- [17]何晓雷,等.美国大学教学学术研究20年:成绩、问题与展望[J].比较教育研究,2012(9):29-33.
- [18]Shulman,L.S.Carnegie Perspectives:A Different Way to Think About Teaching and Learning[J].Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching,2008(5):3.
- [19]Shapiro,H.N.Promotion&Tenure&the Scholarship of Teaching&Learning[J].Change,2006(2):38-43.
- [20]Bender,E.T.CASTLs in the Air:The So TL Movement in Mid-Flight[J].Change,2005(37):40-49.
- [21]Roger Boshier.Why is the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning such a Hard Sell?[J].Higher Education Research&Development,2009(1):1-15.
- [22]Bruce,B.,Henderson&Buchanan,H.E.The Scholarship of Teaching and Learning:a Special Niche for Faculty at Comprehensive Universities?[J].Research in Higher Education,2007(5):523-543.
- [23]Tinberg,H.,Duffy,D.K.&Mino,J.The Scholarship of Teaching and Learning at the Two-Year College:Promise and Peril[J].Change,2007(4):26-33.
- [24]Kreber,C.Controversy and Consensus on the Scholarship of Teaching[J].Studies in Higher Education,2002(2):67-151.
- [25]Trigwell,K.,Martin,E.,Benjamin,J.&Prosser,M.Scholarship of Teaching:a Model[J].Higher Education Research&Development,2000(2):155-168.
- [26]Cottrell,S.A.&Jones,E.A.Researching the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning:An Analysis of Current Curriculum Practices[J].Innovative Higher Education,2003(27):169-181.
- [27]Mc Kinney,K.The Scholarship of Teaching and Learning:Past Lessons,Current Challenges and Future Visions[J].To Improve the Academy,2001(22):6-11.
- [28]Mc Kinney,K.Attitudinal and Structural Factors Contributing to Challenges in the Work of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning[J].New Directions for Institutional Research,2006(129):37-50.
- [29]Ginns,P.,Kitay,K.&Prosser,M.Developing Conceptions of Teaching and the Scholarship of Teaching through a Graduate Certificate in Higher Education[J].International Journal for Academic Development,2008(3):175-185.