促进中小学生论证能力的发展：理论、实践与评价——访哥伦比亚大学教师学院迪安娜·库恩教授Developing Argumentative Competence of Elementary and Secondary Students: Theory,Practice and Evaluation——Interview of Dr. Deanna Kuhn from Teachers College of Columbia University
宋郁,石雨晨
摘要(Abstract)：
作为一项高阶智力活动，论证不仅能帮助学生有效建构知识，还能推动批判性思维等复杂思维能力的发展。越来越多国家的教育研究者和实践者将论证能力视为一项重要的21世纪技能。为了有效培养学生的论证能力，教师应深入了解论证能力的性质、发展轨迹和评价方式。美国哥伦比亚大学教师学院的迪安娜·库恩教授是将论证理论引入教育研究的先驱人物之一，她已在多个国家的中小学课堂开展了大量的实证研究，取得了丰硕的成果。两位访谈者邀请库恩教授深入阐述她30余年来整合教育学、心理学和哲学理论开展论证研究的成果与思考。库恩教授认为论证能力不应仅被视为一种个人技能，还应被视为一种社会文化实践技能。她所倡导的培养论证能力的对话式论证教学法鼓励学生参与论证实践，因而是经验性的。此外，培养论证能力的研究应整合认知、元认知、认识论和情感等多个维度，这样做不仅有助于从理论上更加全面地理解论证能力的本质及特征，还能推动旨在发展学生论证能力的实证研究、教学实践和评价改革。
关键词(KeyWords)： 论证能力;对话式论证教学法;社会文化理论;元认知;认识论;智力价值观
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): 宋郁,石雨晨
参考文献(References)：
- [1] Kuhn,D.,Hemberger,L.,& Khait V.Argue with Me:Argument as a Path to Developing Students' Thinking and Writing [M].London:Routledge,2017.
- [2] Crowell,A.& Kuhn,D.Developing Dialogic Argumentation Skills:A 3-year Intervention Study [J].Journal of Cognition and Development,2014(2):363-381.
- [3][4] Shi,Y.Constructed Dialogs Reveal Skill Development in Argumentive Writing [J].Reading and Writing,2020(9):2311-2335.
- [5] Kuhn,D.& Crowell,A.Dialogic Argumentation as a Vehicle for Developing Young Adolescents' Thinking [J].Psychological Science,2011(4):545-552.
- [6] Kuhn,D.,Zillmer,N.,Crowell,A.,& Zavala,J.Developing Norms of Argumentation:Metacognitive,Epistemological,and Social Dimensions of Developing Argumentive Competence [J].Cognition and Instruction,2013(4):456-496.
- [7] Kuhn,D.,Hemberger,L.,& Khait,V.Tracing the Development of Argumentive Writing in a Discourse-rich Context [J].Written Communication,2016(1):92-121.
- [8] Kuhn,D.A Role for Reasoning in a Dialogic Approach to Critical Thinking [J].Topoi,2018(1):121-128.
- [9] Kuhn,D.Why Is Reconciling Divergent Views a Challenge?[J].Current Directions in Psychological Science,2020(1):27-32.
- [10] Walton,D.Dialog Theory for Critical Argumentation [M].Amsterdam:John Benjamins,2014.
- [11] Billig,M.Arguing and Thinking:A Rhetorical Approach to Social Psychology [M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1987.
- [12] Graff,G.Clueless in Academe:How Schooling Obscures the Life of the Mind [M].New Haven,CT:Yale University Press,2003.
- [13] Vygotsky,L.Problems of General Psychology [A].Rieber,R.& Carlton,A.(Eds.).The Collected Works of L.S.Vygotsky [C].New York,NY:Plenum,1987.
- [14] Kuhn,D.Microgenetic Study of Change:What Has It Told Us?[J].Psychological Science,1995(3):133-139.
- [15] Mercier,H.& Sperber,D.Why Do Humans Reason?Arguments for an Argumentative Theory [J].Behavioral and Brain Sciences,2011(2):57-74.