课件分析视域下的教与学:打开课堂教学黑箱的另一种路径——基于OECD“全球教学洞察”项目的课件评价方法及结果发现Teaching and Learning Through Lens of Artefact Analysis: Another Approach to Opening Black Box of Class Teaching——Based on Methodology and Results from GTI Project by OECD
徐瑾劼,申昕
摘要(Abstract):
近年来,在教育领域,视频研究在我国的发展方兴未艾。视频研究不仅采集视频,以反映教师在课程实施中的行为表现,还同时采集教科书、任务单、作业和演示PPT等课件,以反映教师在预期课程中所设计的学习机会。OECD在全球范围开展的“全球教学洞察”(GIT)项目的特色之一是在统一的评价维度下独立于视频单独对课件进行评分和分析,旨在从课件的视角洞察系统层面各国及地区的教学质量,以丰富教学改进的路径。本研究旨在阐释和分析GTI项目所运用的课件评价方法、技术以及主要的发现,以提出改进我国本地化课件评价研究的建议,包括借助教育智能化发展大规模课件评价,促进“概化理论”(G-Theory)在课件评价质量监测和保障中的应用等。
关键词(KeyWords): OECD;全球教学洞察(GTI)项目;课件分析;评价
基金项目(Foundation): 2022年度“上海浦江人才计划”资助项目“全球人才竞争背景下国际大规模教育测评的生产、传播机制及中国方案研究”(项目编号:22PJC092)的研究成果
作者(Author): 徐瑾劼,申昕
参考文献(References):
- [1][12][13] Martínez,J.,Borko,H.,& Stecher,B.Measuring Instructional Practice in Science Using Classroom Artifacts:Lessons Learned from Two Validation Studies [J].Journal of Research in Science Teaching,2012(1):38-67.
- [2] Matsumura,L.C.,Garnier,H.E.,Slater,S.C.,& Boston,M.D.Toward Measuring Instructional Interactions “At-scale” [J].Educational Assessment,2008(4):267-300.
- [3][4][6][9] OECD.Global Teaching Insights:A Video Study of Teaching [R].Paris:OECD Publishing,2020.
- [5] 徐瑾劼.以学生为主体的“参与式”课堂教学水平的跨国比较——基于OECD全球教学洞察视频研究数据的聚焦分析[J].全球教育展望,2021(1):117-128.
- [7] Center for research on Evaluation,Standards,and Student Testing (CRESST).CSE Technical Report No.707 [R].Los Angeles,CA:University of California,2007.
- [8] Brennan,R.L.Generalizability Theory [M].New York,NY:Springer-Verlag,2001:65.
- [10] Stein,M.& Lane,S..Instructional Tasks and the Development of Student Capacity to Think and Reason:An Analysis of the Relationship between Teaching and Learning in a Reform Mathematics Project [J].Educational Research and Evaluation,1996(2):50-80.
- [11] Matsumura,L.C.,Patthey-Chavez,G.,Valdes,R.,& Garnier,H.Teacher Feedback,Writing Assignment Quality,and Third-grade Students' Revision in Lower-and Higher-achieving Urban Schools [J].The Elementary School Journal,2002(1):3-25.
- [14] 姚鹏飞,屈曼祺,李宝敏.课堂视频分析研究六十年:脉络、热点与发展趋势[J].全球教育展望,2022(3):61-77.